Call or Text Today623-321-4699
Criminal Defense
Criminal Defense overview
Under Investigation
Domestic Violence
Drug Crimes
Property Crimes
Record Relief
Sex Crimes
Theft Crimes
Traffic Offenses
Vehicular Crimes
Violent Crimes
White Collar Crimes
Professional License DefenseArizona Criminal Code Search
DUI
Who We Are
Case Results
Areas We Serve
Blog
Contact
Call Us
Contact Us
Text Us
Call or Text Today 623-321-4699

Violated Probation in Scottsdale? Will You Go to Jail?

Violated Probation in Scottsdale? Will You Go to Jail?

Michael Tamou, Arizona criminal defense attorney

Michael Tamou

Founding Attorney · Criminal Defense

5.0 · Criminal Defense

A probation violation is decided on a lower standard than a conviction—but it doesn’t automatically mean prison. Here’s how the petition-to-revoke process really works.

Recognized By

NTL Top 100 Trial LawyersNTL Top 40 Under 40 Trial LawyersElite Lawyer 2026 Criminal Defense2027 Southwest Super LawyersNational College For DUI DefenseDUI Defense Lawyers Association
Michael Tamou, Arizona criminal defense attorney

Michael Tamou

Founding Attorney · Criminal Defense

★★★★★ 5.0 · Criminal Defense

Written and legally reviewed by Michael Tamou, Founding Attorney of Tamou Law Group, PLLC.

As Seen On

As Seen On NBC News, USA Today, Digital Journal, AZ Central, Lamar, ABC News, Fox News

Recognized By

NTL Top 100 Trial LawyersNTL Top 40 Under 40 Trial LawyersElite Lawyer 2026 Criminal DefenseNational College For DUI DefenseDUI Defense Lawyers Association2027 Southwest Super Lawyers

Featured Answer

What Is a Petition to Revoke Probation?

Violating probation in Scottsdale does not automatically mean jail or prison. Once a petition to revoke probation (PTR) is filed, a judge — not a jury — decides at a violation hearing whether you actually violated a term, using the preponderance of the evidence standard, a far lower bar than the “beyond a reasonable doubt” standard from your original case. If a violation is found, a separate disposition hearing decides what happens next. Under A.R.S. 13-901, a judge can reinstate you on the same terms, add stricter conditions, order up to a year in jail as a condition of continued probation, or revoke probation entirely and impose the prison sentence that was suspended when you were originally placed on probation. A missed check-in and a new arrest are treated very differently.

Michael Tamou Answered by Michael Tamou, Founding Attorney, Tamou Law Group

If your probation officer just told you a petition to revoke probation has been filed, or you missed a check-in and are waiting for the phone to ring, the fear is the same: does this mean the judge who gave you a second chance is about to take it back? The honest answer is that it depends heavily on what you are accused of doing, your record on probation up to this point, and whether the violation is a missed administrative requirement or a brand-new arrest. Arizona law does not treat every violation the same way, and the process that decides your fate — a petition, a hearing, and a separate disposition — gives your attorney real room to work before a judge ever reaches for a jail term.

This page walks through exactly how a Scottsdale probation violation case moves, from the petition to revoke through the disposition hearing, and what actually determines whether you are reinstated, given tougher conditions, or sent to jail or prison. For the full picture of how our firm handles these cases, see our Scottsdale probation violation lawyer page. If you are not sure what happens procedurally after any Scottsdale arrest, including a new arrest while on probation, read our guide to what happens after a Scottsdale arrest.

A petition to revoke probation (PTR) is the formal document that starts this entire process. It is typically prepared by your probation officer and filed with the court that sentenced you, setting out the specific term or terms of probation you are alleged to have violated — a missed drug test, an unpaid fee, a new arrest, contact with a prohibited person, or any other condition from your original sentencing order. Filing a PTR is not a conviction and it is not a finding that you did anything wrong. It is an accusation, and under A.R.S. 13-901(E), the court has discretion to modify your conditions, issue a warrant, or move toward revocation only “in accordance with the Arizona rules of criminal procedure” — meaning the process laid out in Rule 27, Arizona Rules of Criminal Procedure has to be followed before anything is decided.

Once the PTR is filed, you are generally brought before the court for what is often called a revocation arraignment or initial appearance, where the alleged violations are read to you and you are asked to admit or deny each one. Denying the allegations sets the case on the path toward a violation hearing. This is also the point where release conditions get revisited — some probationers stay out of custody pending the hearing, others do not, depending on the nature of the alleged violation and your history. The exact numbering and timing requirements within Rule 27 have been revised over the years, so our team confirms the current deadlines that apply to your specific petition rather than relying on any fixed number here.

Technical vs. New-Offense (Substantive) Violations

Not all probation violations are created equal, and how your case is treated depends heavily on which category yours falls into.

  • Technical violations are failures to comply with the administrative and reporting requirements of probation — missing a scheduled check-in with your probation officer, a missed or failed drug or alcohol test, falling behind on fines, fees, or restitution, not completing a class or community service hours on schedule, moving or traveling without permission, or missing a curfew. None of these involve new criminal conduct; they involve failing to follow the rules of supervision.
  • Substantive (new-offense) violations involve being arrested for, cited for, or charged with a new crime while you are on probation. This is the more serious category, because it usually means you are now facing two proceedings at once — a brand-new criminal case and a violation of your existing probation — and a new arrest is often treated as strong evidence of a violation in its own right.

Arizona judges generally have broad discretion in how they respond to each category, and that discretion is exactly where a defense attorney does the most work. A single missed check-in with a documented explanation — a work conflict, a transportation problem, an honest miscommunication — is not the same case as a new domestic violence or DUI arrest, and it should never be treated that way by the court. Part of the job in a technical-violation case is making sure the judge sees the full context, not just the bare fact that a rule was broken.

⚠️ Warning: Do not assume a technical violation is “no big deal” and skip your revocation arraignment, and do not try to explain yourself directly to your probation officer without talking to a lawyer first. Both a missed hearing and an unguarded explanation can be used against you, and a missed court date on a PTR can trigger a warrant.

What Is the Burden of Proof for a Probation Violation?

The state’s burden at a probation violation hearing is a preponderance of the evidence — meaning the judge only has to find it more likely than not that you violated a term of probation. That is a dramatically lower standard than the beyond a reasonable doubt standard the state had to meet to convict you of the original offense, and it is decided by a judge alone, not a jury. This distinction is one of the most misunderstood parts of the process, and it matters enormously: evidence that might not have been enough to convict you at trial can be enough to prove a probation violation.

This lower standard is also why a pending new criminal charge is dangerous even before that case is resolved. Prosecutors and probation officers frequently move to revoke based on the same conduct underlying a brand-new arrest, and because the preponderance standard applies to the violation hearing, the state may be able to prove the violation even in a case where the new charge itself is weak, contested, or ultimately dismissed. Anyone facing both a new arrest and a PTR needs both cases handled together, by attorneys who understand how each one affects the other.

What Happens at a Probation Violation Hearing?

The violation hearing is where the judge decides whether the alleged violation actually happened. Under Rule 27, Arizona Rules of Criminal Procedure, you have the right to be present, the right to be represented by counsel, the right to receive written notice of exactly what you are accused of violating, the right to present evidence and witnesses on your own behalf, and the right to cross-examine and confront the witnesses against you. Probation violation hearings are generally more relaxed procedurally than a criminal trial — courts have more flexibility with the kind of evidence they can consider than a jury trial would allow — which is exactly why having an attorney who understands these proceedings, and not just criminal trials generally, matters so much.

If the judge finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that you did not violate any of the alleged terms, the petition to revoke is dismissed and your probation continues unaffected. If the judge finds that one or more violations did occur, the case moves to a disposition hearing to decide the consequence. In many Scottsdale cases these two hearings are scheduled close together, or even combined, but they are legally distinct questions: did a violation happen, and if so, what should the court do about it.

The Disposition Hearing: Deciding Your Outcome

A finding that you violated probation is not, by itself, a sentence. The disposition hearing is where the judge decides what actually happens as a result — and this is where the real advocacy in a probation violation case happens. The court can consider your original offense, your overall performance on probation, the seriousness of the specific violation, whether it was your first violation or a repeated pattern, any new charges involved, statements from you and, where applicable, from the victim, and recommendations from your probation officer and the prosecutor.

This is the stage where mitigation matters most. A defendant who shows up with a completed treatment program, stable employment, a documented explanation for a technical slip, and a realistic plan going forward is in a very different position than a defendant who shows up with nothing. Judges retain broad discretion at disposition, and that discretion is precisely why preparation before this hearing — not just showing up — determines outcomes.

Will You Go to Jail or Prison for a Probation Violation?

It depends on the type of violation, your history, and what the judge decides at disposition — but jail or prison is only one point on a spectrum of possible outcomes under A.R.S. 13-901. The court is not limited to an all-or-nothing choice between letting you go and sending you away.

Possible Outcomes After a Probation Violation Is Found

A.R.S. 13-901 · probation conditions, modification & revocation · Rule 27, Ariz. R. Crim. P.

ReinstatementMinor or well-explained technical violation, good record
Result:Probation continues, same terms
Typical for:First-time, isolated technical slip
Modified termsPattern of technical issues or a moderate violation
Result:Added conditions — treatment, monitoring, extended term
Typical for:Repeated missed check-ins, failed tests
Jail as a condition of probationA.R.S. 13-901(H) — up to one year, county jail
Result:County jail term, probation continues after
Typical for:Serious or repeated violations short of revocation
Full revocationSerious new-offense violation or repeated failures
Result:Suspended prison sentence imposed
Typical for:Serious new arrest, repeated substantive violations
A.R.S. 13-901(H) allows a court to require confinement in county jail as a condition of continued probation, capped at one year or the statutory maximum for the offense, whichever is shorter. If probation is revoked outright, the court can impose any prison sentence within the range originally available for your offense — the sentence that was suspended when you were placed on probation. No outcome is guaranteed in either direction; this table describes how Arizona courts generally structure the decision, not a predicted result for any individual case.

Technical violations, especially first-time and well-documented ones, are far more likely to end in reinstatement or modified conditions than in custody. New-offense violations carry much greater risk, both because a new arrest is itself treated as evidence of a violation and because a serious new charge can push a judge toward full revocation. Either way, the outcome is a decision, not a formula — and it is a decision your attorney can influence at every stage, from the revocation arraignment through the disposition hearing.

Key takeaway: A probation violation is decided in two separate steps: a violation hearing, where the state only has to prove a violation by a preponderance of the evidence, and a disposition hearing, where the judge decides the consequence. Outcomes range from reinstatement on the same terms to a full revocation and prison sentence — and the type of violation, your record on probation, and your preparation for disposition all shape where your case lands on that range.

Where Your Scottsdale Probation Violation Case Is Heard

Your probation violation is handled by the same court that sentenced you in the first place — not a separate probation court. A misdemeanor probation case originally sentenced in Scottsdale City Court has its petition to revoke, violation hearing, and disposition hearing heard there, in front of a city court judge, with the city prosecutor handling the state’s side. A felony probation case sentenced in Maricopa County Superior Court has its violation proceedings heard there instead, with the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office prosecuting the petition. If you are unsure which court sentenced you originally, that is the court that controls your violation case — and it is the first thing your attorney should confirm.

If your probation violation stems from a brand-new arrest, you may be dealing with two cases in two different places at the same time — the new criminal charge and the violation proceeding in the original sentencing court — and coordinating both matters enormously to the outcome of each. For background on what happens procedurally after any new Scottsdale arrest, see our guide to what happens after a Scottsdale arrest, and for our general approach to Scottsdale criminal cases, see our Scottsdale criminal defense practice page.

What to Do — and Not Do — After a Violation Allegation

The days right after you learn a PTR has been filed, or right after a missed check-in or a new arrest, are when the most damage is done or avoided. A short list of rules keeps most people from making their situation worse:

  • Do call a defense attorney immediately, before your revocation arraignment, so someone is reviewing the specific allegations and your compliance history before you appear in court.
  • Do gather documentation that explains or contradicts the alleged violation — pay stubs, medical records, texts with your probation officer, proof of enrollment in a class or program.
  • Do keep attending every existing obligation — treatment, community service, check-ins — unless your attorney tells you otherwise; stopping compliance while a PTR is pending makes disposition harder, not easier.
  • Do show up to every scheduled hearing, even if you are afraid of the outcome; missing a hearing on a PTR can trigger a warrant and eliminates any chance to explain yourself.
  • Do not try to explain the alleged violation directly to your probation officer or in writing without talking to a lawyer first — those statements can be used against you at the violation hearing.
  • Do not assume a technical violation will be ignored, or that a first offense guarantees leniency; preparation, not assumptions, is what moves a judge toward reinstatement.
  • Do not ignore a related new criminal charge while focusing only on the probation case — the two proceedings affect each other and need to be handled together.
Our Defense Team

The Experts We Bring to Probation Violation Cases

Winning a disposition hearing is usually about building a complete, credible picture for the judge — compliance history, treatment progress, and an honest account of what happened. We work with the specialists who help build that record.

Mitigation Specialists

Building the Disposition Story

Assemble the employment, family, and compliance history that gives a judge a full, honest picture at the disposition hearing — often the difference between reinstatement and a jail term.

Substance-Abuse & Treatment Evaluators

Documenting Real Progress

Provide independent assessments and treatment verification when a failed test or missed program is at the center of the alleged violation, and connect clients with programs that demonstrate good-faith compliance.

Police Practices Consultants

How the Stop and Search Were Done

Former law enforcement professionals who measure the stop, entry and search against policy, training and lawful procedure.

Private Investigators

Verifying the Alleged Facts

Independently confirm or challenge the facts behind an alleged violation — a missed check-in with a documented reason, a disputed test result, or the circumstances behind a new arrest.

Disposition & Sentencing Counsel

Arguing the Outcome, Not Just the Facts

Focus specifically on the disposition hearing — presenting the full range of options available under A.R.S. 13-901 and building the argument for reinstatement or modified terms over jail or revocation.

Digital Forensics Examiners

Devices, Messages and Metadata

Extract and analyze the complete digital record — messages, locations, deletions — behind the State’s story.

How Tamou Law Group Defends Probation Violations in Scottsdale

The moment we hear a petition to revoke has been filed, we get the petition itself and your full probation file — the original sentencing order, your reporting history, and probation department notes — so we know exactly what is alleged and what your record actually shows. If the allegation is a technical violation, we build the documentation and context that turns an isolated slip into a non-issue at disposition. If a new arrest is involved, we handle both proceedings together, because how the new case is defended directly affects what the state can prove at your violation hearing under the preponderance standard.

At the disposition hearing, our goal is to give the judge every reason to reinstate you or impose modified conditions rather than jail or prison — treatment records, employment verification, and a realistic plan going forward. Our team includes former prosecutors, law enforcement officers, and public defenders who know how Scottsdale City Court and Maricopa County Superior Court actually run these hearings. Call 623-321-4699 for a confidential consultation, or learn more on our Scottsdale probation violation lawyer page and Scottsdale criminal defense practice page. Our Scottsdale office is at 9375 E Shea Blvd, Suite 100, a short drive from Scottsdale City Court.

Award-Winning Criminal Defense Law Firm

When you are looking for the best Phoenix criminal defense lawyers, these are the independently verified credentials that matter, earned by Founding Attorney Michael Tamou and a full team of attorneys, including former prosecutors, public defenders, and law enforcement.

  • National Trial Lawyers Top 100
  • National Trial Lawyers Top 40 Under 40
  • 2027 Southwest Super Lawyers
  • Elite Lawyer 2026, Criminal Defense
  • National College for DUI Defense
  • DUI Defense Lawyers Association

Client reviews

What our clients say

5.0
Based on 109 Google reviewsRead all reviews on Google →
  • I highly recommend Michael Tamou! He recently handled my GCE application, and I couldn't be more grateful for his help. From the very beginning, Michael was incredibly professional, knowledgeable, and thorough in making sure everything was completed perfectly. What stood out the most was his compassion—legal processes can be highly stressful, but he treated me with genuine care, kept me informed, and made me feel completely supported throughout. If you need a dedicated and skilled attorney who truly cares about his clients, look no further than Michael Tamou.

    DMDan MillerGoogle review · Oct 2026
  • Michael Tamou is an exceptional attorney! Facing a case that could affect my future was incredibly stressful, but from our first conversation, he provided honest guidance, reassurance, and a clear plan. He immediately got to work, personally reviewing the evidence and reports, filing the necessary motions, and keeping me informed throughout the process. His expertise, persistence, and genuine care gave me confidence that my case was in capable hands. I’m incredibly grateful that Michael achieved the outcome I had hoped and prayed for: my case was dismissed. I highly recommend him to anyone seeking a skilled, dedicated, and caring attorney.

    TJTammy JohnsonGoogle review · Sep 2026
  • I had a great experience working with Michael. From the beginning, they were professional, knowledgeable, and responsive. They took the time to explain everything clearly, kept me informed throughout the process, and always had my best interests in mind. Their dedication and attention to detail gave me confidence during a stressful time, and they achieved a positive outcome for my case. I truly appreciate their hard work and would highly recommend them to anyone looking for an experienced and trustworthy attorney. Thank so much Tamou Law Group.

    AAAlejandra ArevaloGoogle review · Aug 2026
  • This is a great group of attorneys that work together!! There’s no other law firm I’d use for any situation. They put the time and effort into helping out any way they can. Mike and Kristie were both amazing in handling my situation and being transparent during the whole process.

    TTJ2KGoogle review · Nov 2026
  • I can’t thank Tamou Law Group enough for helping me with my case. They truly went above and beyond, and I’m incredibly grateful for their hard work, dedication, and support. Having a team in your corner that cares makes all the difference during a stressful time. Five stars don’t feel like enough! I highly recommend them to anyone looking for a law firm that will go the extra mile. Thank you for everything!

    EGEvan GibraelGoogle review · Oct 2026
  • I cannot recommend Ms. Jacie Cotterell highly enough. From start to finish, she was absolutely amazing throughout the entire process. She was professional, knowledgeable, and always took the time to answer my questions and explain everything clearly, which gave me a lot of peace of mind during a stressful situation. What stood out most was how genuinely caring and dedicated she was. I always felt like she had my best interests at heart, and her communication was excellent every step of the way. She made a difficult experience much easier to navigate and was always patient, supportive, and reassuring. I am incredibly grateful for all of her hard work and guidance. If you’re looking for someone who is compassionate, trustworthy, and truly committed to helping her clients, I wholeheartedly recommend Ms. Jacie Cotterell. Thank you again for everything, wyou made a lasting positive impact, and I truly appreciate all that you did.

    BPBlaze PeralesGoogle review · Aug 2026
  • Michael is hands down the best in the business. The day I called him he explained everything about my daughter’s situation and took the time to research the charges. He then gave me a price and gave me a chance to think it through before hiring him and two weeks later we retained his services. Michael went to work at that point with his team and brought results that no one else could do. My daughter now has a second chance to get her life on track over a few costly mistakes that could have landed her in prison and with a felony record but Michael did not allow that to happen. If you need solid representation that fights for you then hire Michael.

    RHrob hardeeGoogle review · Aug 2026
  • Kristie & Mike didn’t just see me as another client but as a person in need of help. The level of professionalism & communication going through my whole case made me feel at peace. Amazing lawyers & 10/10 would recommend!

    DNDanny NguyenGoogle review · Oct 2026
  • We {Carrie & Ted S.} are very pleased that we chose Mike Tamou Law Group to represent a criminal case that was against our granddaughter. The case against her was for two different ordeals, and in both situations - the cases were handled above & beyond what we expected. Because of Mike's quickness and professionalism, both situations were resolved in an expedited manor with positive results that we were extremely pleased with. Our granddaughter is also extremely pleased with the results. We would recommend {Mike} Tamou Law Group to anybody that is seeking legal advice in a criminal situation.

    TSTed SchroederGoogle review · Jul 2026
  • I had an aggravated DUI case class 4 felony. With an extensive criminal record of 7 prior felonies. Mr. Tamou did an outstanding job on my case, he got me the least possible amount of time. He got the prosecutor not to allege any of my priers. I did just 4 months with a probation tail. Other lawyers I spoke with prior to retaining M. Tamou, told me the best they could get, would be a few years in prison, due to my extensive criminal history. Michael said he would fight for me and he delivered. He has relationships with the prosecutors and judges and is a great negotiator. Also he was great with communicating with me throughout the process. Always returned my calls and text messages and kept me informed. I highly recommend him.

    PGPaul GonzalezGoogle review · May 2026
  • I had a great experience with Tamou Law! Michael was very helpful. He took the time to explain everything in a way that was easy for me to understand, which made the entire process feel much less overwhelming. He was patient, professional, and always made sure I felt informed and comfortable with each step. I truly appreciated his communication and support throughout! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!

    SSandraGoogle review · Apr 2026
  • Michael is truly amazing. I am so happy that I chose him to help me with my legal situation. He is completely trustworthy. Michael was completely transparent and honest throughout the entire process and offered support to me like I was his own family member. He was patient and understanding and prompt in responding to any of my inquiries during my waiting period. His explanations were clear and logical, and I felt beyond comfortable with him. I really appreciate him and the staff in his practice, and I highly recommend him for anyone's legal needs!! Thank you, Michael! You're really the best. I appreciate you!

    RLRochelle LeeGoogle review · Feb 2026
  • Our family went through the worst time of our lives! It was wonderful to have Michael on our side fighting for us and giving us the advice we needed to take the right steps. Case Dismissed! Thank you for your hard work, dedication, and support.

    RERussell EllisGoogle review · Aug 2026
  • He's the Greatest lawyer we could have ever asked for he put his heart into helping us and we came out with exactly what we wanted! I highly recommend him!

    JOJose OrtizGoogle review · Oct 2026
  • ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I cannot thank Mike Tamou enough for what he did for my family. My son was facing serious charges that could have changed the course of his life forever. From the very beginning, Mr. Tamou treated us with compassion, respect, and honesty. He took the time to explain every step of the process, always making sure we understood what was happening and what to expect. His professionalism and dedication were unmatched. He worked tirelessly on my son’s case, exploring every possible option and fighting for the best outcome. Because of Mike’s skill, expertise, and determination, my son was saved from going to jail and now has the opportunity to move forward and rebuild his life. I am forever grateful for his hard work and would highly recommend Mike Tamou to anyone in need of a strong, knowledgeable, and caring defense attorney. He doesn’t just represent his clients—he truly fight for them.

    EHErin HernandezGoogle review · 2025
  • Michael did an amazing job helping my loved one with his case. He was the first call I made and I knew right then how much he truly cared for his clients. I highly recommend Tamou Law to anyone who reads this review. Michael worked extremely hard for us and exceeded my expectations of the outcome. He is compassionate, very knowledgeable, experienced, respected and very fair. He always took the time to take my calls and to listen to questions that we had. He works hard for his clients and is the kind of guy you want on your side. Thanks again Michael. You were a pleasure to work with.

    LBLaurie BryantGoogle review · 2024
  • Great experience from start to finish. Professional, responsive, and made a stressful situation much easier. I felt confident the whole time and really appreciated Michael’s support. Highly recommend!

    SMShivraj MannGoogle review · Apr 2026
  • Had a situation that Michael helped me through with the best possible outcome. Very responsive and actually cares about his clients.

    CJCaleb JohnsonGoogle review · Aug 2026
  • My son was an idiot and was in serious trouble. He was facing prison time. Fortunately, we were referred to Tamou Law Group by trusted friends and we are beyond grateful that we listened. From the onset, Michael helped to put our family at ease. We discussed the charges where Mike provided insight that helped adjust our expectations. Sure enough, it played out nearly exactly like Mike predicted. Mike put a strong case together – which resulted with no jail time! If you find yourself in need of legal representation, you should hire Michael Timou!

    AHArmando HernandezGoogle review · 2025
  • I can’t recommend Tamou law group enough. From day one, Micheal took the time to really listen, explained my options in a way that actually made sense, and built a strong strategy that put my mind at ease. The entire team was professional, responsive and genuinely caring throughout the whole process. They fought tirelessly and delivered a result that far exceeded my expectations. If you need a law firm you can trust completely, this is it. Thank you!

    BKBryan KingGoogle review · Dec 2025
Why Tamou Law Group

Why Tamou Law Group for Probation Violations

A petition to revoke is not a new trial, and the rules are different: a lower burden of proof, no jury, and a judge who already knows the file. The defense has to be ready before the first hearing, not after.

Probation without jail

Our published results include aggravated DUI, extreme DUI, resisting arrest and unlawful flight cases resolved with probation and no jail. We know what a judge needs to see to keep a client in the community, and we build that record before the hearing.

Former prosecutors on revocation

Former prosecutors on our team know how petitions to revoke are evaluated on the State’s side: which violations the office treats as technical and which it treats as new crimes, and how reinstatement is negotiated.

Two cases at once

A new arrest while on probation creates two cases with two sets of consequences. We defend both together, because a result in one controls what happens in the other.

Published results in this area

CaseChargesOutcome
State v. L.S.Aggravated DUI and suspended license (28-1383, 28-3473)Probation, no jail
State v. H.C.Resisting arrest and disorderly conduct (13-2508, 13-2904)Probation, no jail
State v. J.R.Unlawful flight and criminal damage (28-622.01, 13-1602)Probation, no jail
State v. M.C.Extreme DUI and suspended license (28-1382, 28-3473)Probation, no jail

Anonymized outcomes from our case results page. Every case is different; past results do not guarantee a future outcome.

Call 623-321-4699, 24/7

Common Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Will I go to jail for violating probation in Scottsdale?

Not automatically. A judge first has to find, by a preponderance of the evidence, that you violated a term of probation, and then decide the consequence at a separate disposition hearing. Outcomes range from reinstatement on the same terms to added conditions, county jail as a condition of continued probation, or full revocation with a prison sentence, depending on the type of violation and your record.

What happens at a probation violation hearing?

The judge decides whether the alleged violation actually occurred. You have the right to be present, to be represented by counsel, to receive written notice of the specific allegations, to present evidence and witnesses, and to confront the witnesses against you. If no violation is proven, the petition is dismissed; if one is proven, the case moves to a disposition hearing to decide the consequence.

What is a petition to revoke probation?

A petition to revoke probation (PTR) is the formal document, usually prepared by your probation officer, that alleges you violated a specific term of your probation. Filing a PTR starts the court process under A.R.S. 13-901 and Rule 27, Arizona Rules of Criminal Procedure — it is an accusation, not a finding, and you have the right to contest it at a violation hearing.

What is the difference between a technical and a substantive probation violation?

A technical violation involves failing an administrative requirement of supervision — a missed check-in, a failed or skipped drug test, unpaid fees, or a missed class. A substantive, or new-offense, violation involves being arrested for or charged with a new crime while on probation. Substantive violations are generally treated far more seriously and carry a much higher risk of full revocation.

What is the burden of proof for a probation violation in Arizona?

The state must prove a probation violation by a preponderance of the evidence — meaning it is more likely than not that the violation occurred. This is a much lower standard than the beyond a reasonable doubt standard used to convict you of the original offense, and the decision is made by a judge alone, not a jury.

Can I avoid prison for a probation violation?

Often, yes. Full revocation with a prison sentence is only one possible outcome under A.R.S. 13-901. Many violations, especially first-time technical ones, result in reinstatement or modified conditions instead. A strong showing at the disposition hearing — treatment progress, employment, and a documented explanation — meaningfully affects which outcome a judge chooses. No outcome is ever guaranteed.

Where is a Scottsdale probation violation case heard?

In the same court that originally sentenced you. A misdemeanor probation case is handled in Scottsdale City Court, with the city prosecutor presenting the petition. A felony probation case is handled in Maricopa County Superior Court, with the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office prosecuting it.

Should I talk to my probation officer before I have a lawyer?

Be careful. Explaining an alleged violation directly to your probation officer, in person or in writing, before speaking with an attorney can create statements that are later used against you at the violation hearing. Cooperate with legitimate reporting requirements, but get a lawyer involved before offering any explanation of the alleged violation itself.

Visit Us

Two Arizona Offices, One Team

We serve all of Maricopa County and the surrounding area, with free, confidential consultations 24/7 by phone and in-person meetings at either office by appointment.

Case Results Disclaimer: The results described on this page are based on specific facts and circumstances and do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome in any future case. Every case is different. Past results do not guarantee future results. No attorney-client relationship is formed by viewing this page or submitting a contact form until a written fee agreement has been signed. Tamou Law Group, PLLC is licensed to practice law in the State of Arizona. This website is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

Related Posts:

Free case review

Contact Phoenix’s preferred criminal defense lawyers today

Tell us what happened. An attorney will review your case, explain your options, and start building a defense strategy around your situation.

  • Free and confidential
  • Your case reviewed by our attorneys
  • Phoenix and Scottsdale offices

Prefer to talk now? 623-321-4699

Free case review

Request your free case review

Every request is reviewed by our attorneys.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name*

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Secure & confidentialFree consultation

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship.